Some people seem to really enjoy the articles posted by the content bot, but others seem to think that the bot post too many articles and clog up their RSS feeds. Come give us your opinion in the straw poll.
You must log in or register to comment.
I personally hate seeing tens of hundreds of articles without replies. If I wanted an RSS feed I would get one.
Same.
As someone who uses the actual rss feeds, reading the same feed without interaction is just … a waste of time. Clutter. Annoying even.
Like you said: I come here for the interaction and/or to find an interesting article someone found in a channel I’m unaware off. Not bot rss feed content.
Fully agree. Instead of having a bot posting articles there should be a sticked thread or a wiki to list interesting sources and their RSS. User could add them to their RSS client if they want. When they have a reaction then they could share on Lemmy and comment it.
Lemmy and Tildes has really shown me how much more interesting information is when it’s given by a real person with some context or an opening post.
A news article posted by a bot to… farm karma on Lemmy?? It’s just noise. Many of such articles posted have clickbait titles and comments under them tend to have less value and are based around uniformed opinions coming from the (often misleading) title alone.
Quality aside, I guess I don’t really see the point. To who’s benefit are bot content posted? It feels like advertising to me. I’d like to think that the community are able to sustain itself by the content someone cared enough about to bother post it here.
In short, bot created content is noise to me, while content posted by real persons has value.
I think it also depends on the rate of bot posts, when they post many posts within the same minute it’s just a wall of posts with little value, for example there’s 100 posts so each post will at most get 0-2 comments.
If the bot instead adds a single post once a hour/day depending on how active the channel is it could be fine. Because then people have time to discuss each post.
I recall that L4s’ owner stated that the bot’s purpose was to “jumpstart communities”. Personally, having noticed how much it has posted, and what ratio of top posts belong to it over time, it’s achieved just that.
I think it was a nice thing to have early on. But maybe its time has come.
I don’t disagree, I think L4s has done a good job here and have thought it might be time to pull the plug for almost 2 weeks now.
My only worry is that it creates a gap in conversations (due to less posts here), which might slow or reverse some of the growth, but that would be inevitable no matter when we decide to do it.
That’s why I think @PopBobert@lemmy.world’s poll is a good idea, if the community thinks it’s time then let’s do it.
maybe they should be going to a different community? similar to !news_tech@lemmy.link or something
maybe upvoted posts there could automatically be crossposted here? idk I agree the bots are annoying but I use the bot communities sometimes to look for something interesting to crosspost elsewhere
or maybe all the links could be grouped into a daily post? but then people would likely ignore it entirely
So far there are only 89 votes on this poll. I don’t think that represents the community very well when we regularly get posts with 1000 upvotes.
I never saw this when it was new. I don’t know if it was ever pinned, but, if not, maybe that would have given this more traction due to visibility? I think post like this from just yesterday show it’s still divisive.
My client has an option to include content from bots, or not. Seems reasonable for people to choose
So does mine, it didnt change anything
Here on !technology@lemmy.world you shouldn’t see posts from @L4s@lemmy.world with that checked, and any other bot that is marked properly.
If you come across bots not marked so in any Lemmy.World community, please report it as it goes against the latest rules of this instance, we can involve the admins and ask them to intervene.
Id prefer a bot only community. I already have rss feeds
VPN user voting not allowed. Great job guys! I’m not turning off my VPN for any site.
This is just to try and combat single users voting more than once, but totally understand not turning it off.
I understand it too, but is there no way to make a poll in lemmy?
Not currently, at least that we have been made aware of
Too many links without enough conversation. Maybe dial it waaaay back.
… just block the bot if you don’t like it. It’s not complicated.
