• 0 Posts
  • 26 Comments
Joined 4 months ago
cake
Cake day: December 2nd, 2025

help-circle



  • I know this is a bit of an extreme example. Leaving an abusive spouse leads to suicides. You can’t blanket assign responsibility in all cases. It needs to be reasonable.

    In cases of targeted harassment, sure. I think cases like that have gone to trial.

    But if seeing someone walk into a book signing by a woman with regressive views on trans related stuff tips someone over the edge to suicide I don’t feel that’s reasonably assignable blame. Seeing J.K.Rowling succeed is such a minor thing compared to the child raping cannibal cults we have running things. It just does not even register.

    Calls to violence are outright crimes where I live, whether any violence occurs or not. I think you might get a lighter sentence if nothing happens, not sure. Just like you don’t get off with no charges if you shoot at someone and miss.






  • I personally feel that it’s perfectly fine to boycott problematic figures. Speech has real effects and should be treated like it.

    But once you accept the equivalence of speech/reading and violence you can start choosing to regulate speech/reading as violence, or free up violence as speech. I don’t think either is a great idea. Do you think that any of you have never said something hurtful to others? Should you be jailed for it?

    I await all the civil and non-hurtful replies from peaceful and sympathetic people I am likely to garner for this stance.









  • Well, it’s nuanced for one thing.

    The USA has a violence issue, and legal civilian gun ownership is at most an exacerbating factor. The current regulatory climate towards guns likely causes the most harm in accidents and suicides. But it certainly causes some harm.

    Criminals are using illegally sourced guns already, so bans will have no effect there.

    Firearms safety courses before you get a license and access to mental health services would be far more effective than yet another weapons ban and more politically palatable to the population. But that doesn’t make for a good wedge issue to rally the faithful behind.

    Or an actual social safety net and a living wage, because violence is far more strongly correlated with poverty and income inequality.