• 3 Posts
  • 19 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 24th, 2023

help-circle





  • If the new wording was appended to the statement instead of replacing it, I would agree with you.

    But the word “every” is a guaranteed inclusion (while not explicitly excluding anyone), while “only” is a guaranteed exclusion (while not explicitly including anyone).


    For a dumb example, my chili recipe says “every type of bean may be used”, I can put black beans and pinto beans in it, and no one can tell me otherwise. But if I change it to “only beans may be used”, that is more open to further restrictions by later stipulations.

    “Do not use pinto beans” is in direct contradiction with “every type of bean may be used”.

    “Do not use pinto beans” is actually not a contradiction with “only beans may be used”.


    What I’m seeing with the new language is that a new law saying something like “Students who continue to live with their parents are not permitted to participate in elections” is actually permissible and not in contradiction with the statement "Only a United States citizen age 18 or older who is a resident of an election district in this state is a qualified elector of that district.”

    At least according to the constitution. Prior to Nov 5, it would be unconstitutional in WI to pass such a law, that’s no longer the case.